- Home
- Basic Embroidery Stitches
- Thread Painting
SURFACE EMBROIDERY TECHNIQUE
Thread Painting for Beginners
Learn the secrets to smooth shading with long and short stitch, and create a beautiful embroidered flower
A completed thread painted flower, the project you'll learn to create
Thread painting, commonly known as needle painting or silk shading, is a unique embroidery technique that employs long and short stitches to create exquisite, nuanced works of art on fabric.
Despite the simple nature of the stitches, this technique can be a challenging but rewarding skill to master.
I know this firsthand. I first tried this as a teenager and struggled to get a neat effect.
It wasn't until I returned to it in my fifties that I discovered the incredible beauty that is attainable. It took trial and error, but I learned the secrets to achieving that beautiful, soft shading effect that makes this art form so special.
The Essentials: Techniques and Materials
Before you thread your needle, understanding a few key concepts is crucial for success. Getting these fundamentals right will save you from the most common frustrations.
Choosing the Right Thread
While the term "silk shading" might suggest the use of pure silk, thread painting can be done using various types of threads.
Embroidery Floss
The most common and economical choice. It yields fantastic results and has a soft sheen that is perfect for flower petals or animal fur. This guide uses standard embroidery floss.
Pure Silk
This thread results in exceptionally lustrous and beautiful work, but it is more expensive.
Crewel Wool
Also a popular choice, wool offers a different texture and a softer, more matte finish.
Mastering the Core Technique
The actual stitch in thread painting may look straightforward, because it is a straight stitch. Achieving the blended, seamless effect is where the skill lies.
The Three Things That Make the Difference
The Single-Strand Secret
The number one secret is to use a single strand of embroidery floss. My first failed attempts used three strands, which creates a chunky, uneven result. A single strand allows you to build up colour and shade delicately, like a painter with a fine brush.
Rethinking "Long and Short Stitch"
The term itself can be misleading. In reality, only the very first foundational row features stitches of truly varying lengths. The staggered edge created by this first row is what allows for smoother, invisible transitions between subsequent rows and colours.
Avoid the Gaps
This is the most important technical tip. To create a smooth surface, you must bring your needle UP through the existing stitches of the previous row. If you push the needle DOWN through them, you will create noticeable holes and disrupt the blend.
Step-by-Step Tutorial: Your First Flower
To help you get started, follow this simple tutorial to create a shaded flower petal.
What You'll Need
- Fabric (like a simple cotton or linen)
- 5 shades of embroidery floss (from light to dark)
- A fine embroidery needle with a small eye
- A design transfer tool (like a quilter's pencil or disappearing ink pen)
- An embroidery hoop
The Free Flower Practice Sheet
Print the flower used in this tutorial, at both learning size and stitching size, with the stitch directions marked and the five colour zones numbered. There is a blank flower on it too, for planning your own shades.
Prepare Your Design
I chose 5 shades of Anchor stranded cotton for this sample flower, going from light to dark: 1026, 968, 1016, 1018, 1028.
Transfer a simple design onto your fabric. I sketched a five-petaled flower with a quilter's pencil, which washes out.
Stitching the First Row
Using your palest shade and a single strand of floss, stitch the first row of long and short stitches along the outer edge of the petal.
Vary the lengths of these stitches significantly to create a staggered, uneven inside edge.
Fig. 1: The first row of long and short stitch
Creating the Second Row
Using your second darkest colour, work the next row.
Bring your needle UP through the stitches of the previous row, filling in the gaps and blending the two shades. Start your stitches at different points to avoid creating a hard line.
Maintain a staggered bottom edge for this row as well.
Fig. 2: The next row of stitches in place
Where two colours meet
Decide how far the two colours will travel into each other before you start the row.
The instinct is to stitch up to where the first colour ended and stop. Blending needs traffic in both directions instead. Take some of your new stitches well up past the ends of the pale row, further than looks comfortable, and leave others short. Then, when you come to thread the pale shade again for any gaps, bring a few of those stitches back down into the darker area.
The two colours should end up interleaved like fingers, not stacked like bricks.
This is also the row to drop to a single strand if you have not already. One strand can be worked in between existing stitches in a way two strands cannot, and it will not twist against itself.
Adding Subsequent Rows
Continue adding rows with your subsequent colours, always directing the stitches towards the flower's centre.
Continue the technique of bringing the needle up through the previous row's stitches to blend the colours smoothly.
Fig. 3: Adding the third shade
On a curved petal
Change the angle on every stitch, not every few stitches.
A curve is not a series of straight runs with turns between them. If you work five stitches at one angle, then five at the next, the petal will read as a set of flat panels however smooth each panel is.
The check to use while you are stitching: imagine the line of the stitch you are about to make carried on past the petal edge. It should arrive at the centre of the flower. Every stitch, all the way round, including the ones near the sides where the angle feels most extreme. Those side stitches will look as though they are leaning hard, and they are supposed to.
Where one group of angles meets the next, stitches will appear to cross rather than sit in parallel. Let them.
Completing the Petal
Add your final rows, using the darkest shade sparingly to create shadows and depth.
Don't worry if the outside edge isn't perfectly smooth. You could add a row of split stitch around the petal before you begin, but this isn't necessary for all projects.
Fig. 4: The darkest shade in place
Where the petal meets the centre
Decide how many stitches will fit before the shape closes.
The petals narrow as they reach the flower centre, and five of them are converging on the same small area. There is far less room there than at the outer edge, and carrying a full row of full-length stitches into it packs thread into the smallest part of the design.
Reduce the count as you go. Where the widest part of the petal took eight stitches side by side, the last rows might take four, then two. Shorten them as well.
If you knit, it is the same idea as decreasing. Once you are past the widest part, every row takes a few stitches fewer than the one before it.
This is also where your darkest shade goes, and dark thread shows crowding more than a pale one does. That is the real reason to use it sparingly.
Finishing the Flower
Work each petal of the flower in the same way. The photograph at the top of the page shows my completed flower sample. I used a hand-dyed thread to work French knots for the centre and stem stitch for the stem.
Fig. 5: Working the third petal
Why Thread Painting Goes Wrong
Long and short stitch looks wrong until it is finished. That is not encouragement, it is how the technique behaves.
While large areas of fabric are still bare, there is nothing for the blending to blend into. Every join shows. Every gap looks like it will be there forever. Stitchers who have done a great deal of silk shading will tell you their work seems to get steadily worse until near the very end, when it suddenly pulls together.
So before we look at what genuinely goes wrong, here are three things you have probably already decided you have ruined.
Three Things That Look Like Mistakes
The blend looks stripey and you are two petals in
You cannot read a blend with half the shape still empty. The bands only start to merge once the colours either side of them are in place, so a partly filled petal will always show its joins. Judge it when it is filled, not before.
The stitches look messy close up
You have been six inches from your own work for two hours. Every stitch has been inspected on its own, which is not how anyone will ever look at the finished piece. Pin it up on the other side of the room and look again. Your eye has been lying to you.
It does not look like the photograph
Very often that is the thread rather than your hands.
A tutorial worked in very fine cotton, or in silk, gives a smoothness that stranded cotton will not give you at the same strand count. When a tutorial like that tells you to use two strands, it means two strands of its own thread. Two strands of stranded cotton is a heavier thread altogether, and it will come out thicker and blockier however carefully you place each stitch. Some tutorials add another layer to this by using variegated floss and choosing exactly where along the colour run each stitch falls, which is a kind of blending you cannot reproduce with single colour skeins at all.
So the first question to ask is not "what am I doing wrong". It is "am I working with the same material". If the answer is no, the gap between your petal and the photograph is not a gap in your skill, and no amount of practice will close it.
My First Attempt, and What Went Wrong
As you work, don't be afraid to make adjustments. My initial drawing for the flower in this tutorial was rather lopsided, so I adjusted the shape of the petals as I embroidered to make it more balanced.
I want to show you one of my early attempts. My apologies for the awful drawing!
My first attempt at thread painting
I used three strands of floss for this attempt, which is why it looks chunky instead of smooth. You can also see the holes where I went down through the existing stitches, instead of bringing the needle up through them.
Both of those are on the list below. I made two of the three classic faults in a single flower, which is why this photograph has stayed on the page.
The Three Faults That Are Real
Hard stripes where two colours meet
Each colour ended in a neat, level row, so there is nothing for the next shade to reach up into.
Fabric showing between the stitches
The stitches are spaced too far apart, and the needle is going down through the previous row instead of coming up through it.
Petals looking blocky instead of curved
The stitches are not turning to follow the shape, and two strands have twisted together instead of lying flat.
None of these mean starting again. Each one is a change you make in the next stitch, not a reason to unpick the last hundred.
Hard Stripes Where Two Colours Meet
Hard stripes come from ending each colour at the same level.
If every stitch in a band finishes in a tidy row, the next colour has no choice but to start where that row stopped, and the join becomes a line. Long and short stitch blends because the stitch lengths within a band vary and the bands interlock. Take the variation out and you get stacked stripes instead.
There are two separate fixes, and you can use either or both.
Make the first band longer than feels necessary. The most common version of this fault is a first row of short, even stitches, which leaves the next colour nowhere to go. Work that first band long, longer than looks right at the time, and carry some of its stitches well down into the area the next colour will fill. You are leaving room for the blend to happen.
Narrow the colour steps. A sharp jump between two shades draws the eye straight to the join, and any unevenness along it becomes obvious. That is not wrong in itself, and a stark change is sometimes exactly what a design wants. But it will never give a soft blend, and it is unforgiving of stitching that is not yet even. Closely related shades hide the same imperfections. If your blending is still finding its feet, choose shades that sit nearer one another and the technique will flatter you rather than expose you.
Fabric Showing Between the Stitches
Gaps are a spacing problem, not a thread problem or a fabric problem.
Long and short stitch depends on stitches sitting immediately beside one another, close enough that the fabric cannot show through. Beginners routinely leave more space than they realise, then try to solve it by going back over the fill again and again.
There is an uncomfortable answer here that is worth saying plainly. The fill really does need stitches placed that close together, near enough hole by hole. A lot of people come to thread painting to get away from the strictness of counted work, and find that closing the gaps asks for the same care they were escaping. The freedom in thread painting is in how long the stitches are and where they point. It is not freedom from precision.
Coming up through existing thread splits and packs the previous stitches rather than dragging them aside, and that is what closes the small holes along a blending edge. Going down through them does the opposite, which is exactly what happened in my flower above. It costs nothing to apply, and it is a rule that slips once you are working quickly, so it is worth checking every time you sit down.
Petals That Look Blocky Instead of Curved
Blocky petals are usually two faults at once: the stitches are not turning, and the strands are not lying flat.
The stitches are not turning enough. In thread painting, stitch direction is dictated by the subject, not by the weave of the fabric. On a flower, every stitch in a petal points towards the centre of the flower, which means the angle changes continuously as you work round the petal. The change should be gradual and constant, not saved up for the edge.
Where the angle shifts between neighbouring groups of stitches, the stitches appear to cross over one another rather than sitting in tidy parallel rows. That crossing is correct. It looks like freestyling and it is not. If you have been trying to keep your rows neat and parallel, that instinct is what is squaring off your petals.
The fix is to stop judging every angle by eye. Draw your direction guidelines straight onto the fabric before you start, in pencil or marker, radiating in towards the flower centre. The stitching covers them, so they only ever serve you while you work.
The strands are not lying flat. Two strands that have twisted around each other sit up in a little rope instead of lying flat side by side, and a fill made of ropes reads as blocky no matter how well placed the stitches are. Railroading stops this: before you push the needle down into the fabric, slip it between the two strands and hold them apart as you pull the thread through.
Better still, use fewer strands. The standard for needle painting is two strands for the outline and the outermost band of colour, then a single strand for every shade blended in after that. A single strand cannot twist against itself, which is one of the reasons experienced thread painters blend with one. My chunky flower above was worked in three.
Patience Makes Perfect
Achieving a smooth, painterly finish requires practice and patience. Remember that even the most skilled thread painters started with their first try.
Every artist starts with an imperfect attempt. Learn from your mistakes, and soon you will be able to create stunning thread painted pieces of your own.
Stitchin' Times Newsletter
Stay connected between projects
If you'd like occasional updates from my embroidery room, including new patterns, gentle tips, and little things I think you might enjoy, you're warmly invited to join the Stitchin' Times newsletter.
About Me - Contact Carol - Privacy Policy - Site Map - Testimonials
Please do not copy the content of this site. It is protected by Copyscape.
Copyright © 2006- www.needlework-tips-and-techniques.com All rights reserved