Cross stitch vs embroidery:
Which suits you best?

If you've ever been curious about the differences between cross-stitch vs embroidery, you're not alone!

Embroidery and cross stitch are two of the most popular stitching techniques, and each has unique characteristics and benefits. In this article, we'll explore the differences between the two, so you can make an informed decision when selecting the right stitching technique for your next project.

Embroidery and cross stitch are commonly confused, and for good reason – they share many similarities! Both can produce beautiful pieces of work. However, the two needlecrafts are actually quite different.

A Short Definition of Embroidery

Embroidery is a form of decorative needlework used to create designs on fabric using a variety of stitches and threads. The fabric tends to be closely woven and plays little part in the positioning of each stitch.

The pattern is transferred onto the cloth either by the kit manufacturer or by the embroiderer. This can be done using an iron-on transfer, a disappearing ink pen, or a sharp graphite pencil.

Care should be taken to keep the lines as narrow as possible, to reduce the possibility of them showing once the stitching is complete.

old iron on transfersOld iron on embroidery transfers


A Short Definition of Cross Stitch

Cross stitch, however, depends on the fabric's weave to determine where the stitches are placed. The fabric most beginners try is Aida, which is block woven to leave regularly spaced holes for the needle to pass through.

With experience, the cross stitcher may move on to linen or cotton evenweave fabrics. These are created by weaving a series of parallel warp threads over and under an equal number of weft threads. This ensures that each cross stitch is the same size.

Instead of transferring an image directly to the fabric (as in embroidery), the design is worked by counting stitches from a gridded pattern or chart. Each thread color is represented by a unique symbol. If you haven't tried it before my learn how to cross stitch page will get you started. 

Equipment Needed

Types of Fabric

jobelan cross stitch fabric

Whatever technique you decide to use, it is critical to use quality fabric. Hand embroidery and cross stitch pieces are often passed down the generations, so you will want them to stand the test of time.

Aida is 100% cotton, and the other evenly woven fabrics you might use are typically cotton, linen or a mix of viscose and natural fibers.

If you prefer embroidery, you have a wider choice of surfaces to work on. This can range from fine muslin or silk up to thick canvas or hessian.

Types of Thread

pearl cotton balls

With embroidery, the world is your oyster regarding the threads and fibers you can use. You can choose to work with whatever you like, thick, thin, shiny, or matt.

However, when working on a cross-stitch design, a pattern will normally call for stranded embroidery floss, often from a single brand. On occasion, a blending filament or metallic thread can also be incorporated, as can seed beads.

Different Types of Needles

crewel needles

A key distinction between embroidery and cross stitch is the types of needles used. Embroidery needles have a sharp point, which makes it easy to pierce the fabric.

Cross stitch needles are blunt so that they DON'T pierce the fabric, and instead slip between the threads. This keeps the stitches in the correct position creating neat work.

Time Commitment

When it comes to cross stitch vs embroidery, the amount of time commitment required can vary greatly.

Embroidery is generally faster than cross stitch because you don't have to count the stitches on the chart and then on your work.

However, this does not mean embroidery will always take less time than cross stitching.

Creating an intricate pattern with many colors and stitches could take just as long (or longer) than a simpler design done in a traditional cross stitch style.

Ultimately, the amount of time needed depends upon what type of project you're working on and how much detail is involved - so be sure to factor this into your decision when selecting between these two types of needlework.

Design Possibilities

The possibilities for design with both techniques are endless!

Cross stitching is all about arranging a series of small squares on a grid – but beware, curved shapes and lines can be tricky. However, you can still create beautiful designs despite working within these constraints. Careful use of color will greatly enhance the overall effect of your design.

The more complex the design, the more experience you will need to complete it – so if you're a beginner, you may want to choose a simple pattern first to gain confidence in your abilities.

In contrast, embroidery allows you to combine stitches to create realistic pictures, textures, and even a certain amount of dimensionality. Without following a grid or chart, you have the freedom to create whatever you want.

Both techniques offer unique ways of expressing yourself through needlework - from traditional motifs like flowers and animals to more modern patterns like abstract shapes and geometric figures.

Ultimately, the choice is yours when deciding which technique best suits your project!

Level of Detail

When deciding between embroidery or cross stitch, the level of detail is a major factor.

Embroidery offers more intricate designs than traditional cross-stitching due to its use of different stitches and threads. With embroidery, you can create complex patterns with subtle shading that would be difficult in regular cross stitch - unless your design is huge!

On the other hand, if you're looking for something simple or quick to make, then basic cross-stitch might be right up your alley!

Which will you choose?

No matter which type of stitching you choose, let your creativity shine through and have fun. With your newfound skills, you can create beautiful items to last a lifetime. You may even find yourself enjoying both types of stitching equally as much!

You might like these

Keep in Touch with Stitchin'Times Newsletter